The rules, side by side
The US Federal Trade Commission’s rule on reviews took effect on 21 October 2024. It bans fake reviews (including AI-generated ones), buying reviews, rewards tied to positive sentiment, undisclosed insider reviews, fake review sites you control, and suppressing reviews by threats. Google, Yelp and Trustpilot each go further.
| Practice | FTC rule | Yelp | Trustpilot | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ask customers at all | Yes | Yes | No | Yes |
| Ask only happy customers | Risky | No | No | No |
| Offer a reward for any review | Allowed if not tied to sentiment | No | No | No |
| Reward for positive reviews | No | No | No | No |
| Staff or family reviews | Only with disclosure | No | — | No |
| Write or buy reviews | No | No | No | No |
“Risky”: the FTC says asking only happy customers isn’t specifically banned by the rule but could violate the FTC Act. Google bans all review incentives, even ones not tied to sentiment.
Fair asking vs gating
“Review gating” means checking whether a customer is happy before sending the review link. Google, Yelp and Trustpilot all prohibit it.
Step by step
-
Step 1: Write down your review policy
Ask every customer, whatever their experience. No rewards. Staff and family don’t review. No quotas for staff.
-
Step 2: Get your Google review link or QR code
On a computer, go to business.google.com › Read reviews › Get more reviews. Click Copy for the link, or right-click the QR code to save it. QR codes can only be made in a computer browser.
Illustration. Get more reviews: copy the link (1) or save the QR code (2). -
Step 3: Choose one moment for everyone
Google suggests receipts, thank-you emails, the end of a chat, or a printed QR code in your shop. Pick one point, such as the thank-you message after every job, and use it for every customer. Don’t hand customers a tablet to review on the spot: Google forbids pressuring people on your premises.
-
Step 4: Send neutral wording
No stars, no suggested wording, no naming a staff member. Use these as a starting point:
Say- “We read every review, good or bad.”
- “If you have a minute, you can leave an honest review.”
Never say- “Loved us? Leave 5 stars!”
- “Get 10% off when you review.”
- “Unhappy? Contact us instead of posting.”
- “Please mention Sam by name.”
Hi Sam,
Thanks for choosing Harlow & Reed on 14 November. We read every review, good or bad, and use them to improve.
If you have a minute, you can leave an honest review here: g.page/r/…/review
Thanks,
Alex, Harlow & Reed PlumbingHarlow & Reed, 12 Mill Lane, Northgate · Unsubscribe
Template. An email and a text that follow the rules. Only text customers who agreed to receive texts. -
Step 5: Don’t ask for Yelp reviews
Yelp says businesses should never ask customers to write reviews, and its software filters solicited reviews. You can mention you’re on Yelp.
-
Step 6: Reply to reviews
In Read reviews, choose the reply icon, write, and click Reply. Replies are public and the reviewer is notified. Keep them short, polite and personal; don’t promote offers; never reveal private details; apologise for real mistakes and move complex issues to phone or email.
Fake or abusive reviews
Google removes only reviews that break its policies, not ones you disagree with.
What to expect
- A review report typically takes several days.
- Replies usually appear within 10 minutes, occasionally up to 30 days.
- If Google finds fake engagement, it can remove reviews, block new ones for a period and show a warning on the profile, after emailing you.
What this can’t do
- You can’t make a platform remove a truthful negative review.
- More reviews may help how prominent you are, but Google promises no ranking.
- AI tools read reviews, but asking for them doesn’t let you control what they say.
Common mistakes
-
Review gatingIncluding “rate us 1–5 first” funnels.
-
An “honest review” discountThe FTC may allow it; Google and Trustpilot don’t.
-
Staff or relatives reviewingWithout disclosure it’s illegal; on Google it’s banned outright.
-
Asking for stars or a nameKeep the request neutral.
-
Threatening to sueBanned under the FTC rule.
-
The same pasted replyWrite each reply for the person.
Sources
Checked against the official pages on 16 November 2026. Platforms change their screens and rules often; if something looks different, follow the official page.
- FTC: Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule, Questions and Answers — incentives, selective asking, employees
- Google Maps user-generated content policy — fake engagement, incentives, selective asking
- Google Business Profile: Share a link or QR code to get reviews