Why answers differ
The same question can get different answers for different people. ChatGPT uses your approximate location and, if memory is on, saved memories. Gemini uses your general location and memory; AI Mode can use your Search history; Copilot uses saved memories and activity across Microsoft services. So test in a clean session, and treat one run as a sample, not a verdict.
The prompts
Use these exact wordings every time, so this month’s results compare with next month’s.
Who is [Full Name]?What does [Full Name] do?[Full Name] [Company]What is [Business] known for?Is [Business] any good? What do customers say?Best [service] in [City][Business] reviews and complaintsWho founded [Business] and when?
Clean sessions, sources, feedback
| Engine | Clean session | Where sources show | How to report |
|---|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | New chat › Temporary › Unpersonalized | Inline citations and the Sources button | 👎 › Select an issue |
| Gemini | Temporary chat, next to New chat | Sources button below the answer | Bad response; More › Report legal issue (not in temporary chats) |
| AI Overviews | Signed out or private window (our suggestion) | Links inside the overview | 👎 › Report a problem › Submit |
| AI Mode | google.com/ai, signed out (our suggestion) | Links in the answer | 👎 › choose a category |
| Perplexity | Incognito (memory always off) | Numbered citations | No official help page found |
| Copilot | Turn off Saved memories and One shared experience; keep Web search on | Links in the answer | Flag icon, or Settings › Give feedback |
From each vendor’s help pages, November 2026. Labels change often.
Step by step
-
Step 1: Set up your tracking sheet
One row per engine per prompt. Keep it in any spreadsheet.
Date Engine Prompt Answer summary Accurate? Sources cited Action 16 Nov Perplexity Who is Jane Example? COO of Example Corp Yes linkedin.com, example-corp.com — 16 Nov ChatGPT Who is Jane Example? “VP Operations at Sample Inc.” No oldconference.org/2016 Contact organiser; update own site 16 Nov Gemini Who is Jane Example? Mixes her with a namesake Partly facebook.com/… Report; strengthen own pages Template. A tracking sheet with three example rows. The red row is the one to act on. -
Step 2: ChatGPT
Start a new chat, choose Temporary, then Unpersonalized before your first message; “Personalized” can still use your memories. Turn on search from the tools menu (or type “/” and pick Search), ask each prompt, and open Sources.
-
Step 3: Gemini
At gemini.google.com, click Temporary chat next to “New chat”. After each answer, open Sources; if there’s no Sources button, Gemini cited nothing.
-
Step 4: Google AI Overviews and AI Mode
AI Overviews appear in normal search only when Google chooses to show one. For AI Mode, go to google.com/ai or choose AI Mode after a search. Using a signed-out or private window to reduce personalisation is our suggestion; Google doesn’t say how much it changes.
-
Step 5: Perplexity
Use Incognito, where memory and previous searches are always off. Answers show numbered citations.
-
Step 6: Copilot
In Settings › Personalization, keep Web search on and, for a cleaner run, turn off Saved memories and One shared experience.
-
Step 7: Save everything the same day
Screenshot each answer and copy every cited address into the sheet.
-
Step 8: Repeat monthly
Same prompts, same clean settings, new rows. Monthly is our suggestion; answers change as sources change.
Trace a wrong answer
Open the source cited for the wrong sentence and check whether it really says it. OpenAI notes citations can be incomplete or wrong.
- Is the wrong fact on your page or profile? YesUpdate it, and every other copy. Bio guide. NoCheck the next question.
- Is it on someone else’s page? YesAsk the publisher to correct it. For broker sites, opt out. NoNo source: the model made it up.
- In every case ReportUse the engine’s feedback button (table above). StrengthenPublish clear, accurate sources about you.
What this can’t do
- You can’t edit an AI answer. You can fix sources, give feedback, or make legal and privacy requests.
- No engine publishes how quickly it acts on feedback or re-reads a corrected page.
- Removing data from an engine doesn’t remove it from the web.
Common mistakes
-
Testing signed in with memory onThen assuming everyone sees the same.
-
Not recording sourcesThe source is what you fix.
-
Arguing with the chatbotFix the cited page instead.
-
Trusting a citation unopenedCheck that it really says the claim.
-
Changing the promptsResults stop being comparable.
-
Feedback from a temporary Gemini chatFeedback isn’t available there.
Sources
Checked against the official pages on 16 November 2026. Platforms change their screens and rules often; if something looks different, follow the official page.
- OpenAI Help: Searching the web with ChatGPT — Search tool, Sources button, location and memory
- Gemini Help: Sources in responses
- Google Search Help: AI Overviews — Report a problem; Web filter